More on the late Chan Tai-San

2 Sep

You can buy “Authentic Lama Pai: The teachings of the late Chan Tai-San” at

Sifu chan Tai-San had both Chinese and American students. The Americans were the majority at the Gee How Oak Tin Association on Bayard street. That was really because Chinese students would often come, were confronted with Sifu’s personality head on, and would opt for another arrangement.


I think sifu was even harder on his Chinese students, he expected they know every aspect of the “proper” things to do in the kung fu world, even if they were “juk sing” (ABC)… Considering the grief he gave me, an American with no previous Chinese cultural training, over stuff like the right place to put a tea cup or the correct time to pour tea, I can only imagine the sort of stuff he expected of Chinese students…


Other times, Sifu Chan would be contacted by all Chinese groups to teach on a contract basis. Sifu Chan, as was his nature, would of course take the money, then often mess with the heads of those groups. It was like “I am Chan Tai San, and I thumb my nose at you and your thinking you are anyone”

Sifu Chan’s favorite “trick” was to take the money and then have a monkey, usually me, a lowly gwai loh, do the actual teaching. I got used to the drill. He’d tell me to show up some place at a certain time. By the time I’d shown up, Sifu had taken the money and closed the deal, he’d usually start something with the group. Then, as soon as I arrived, he’d hand them all over to me and LEAVE…. I taught in the White Crane school, and in 4 or 5 different “associaitons” over the years because of this “trick”…


I remember two times when this created an actual argument. The head of one of the associations was absolutely not going to accept a dumb monkey teaching his members, especially when he thought he had paid for famous Chan Tai san. Sifu Chan simply told the guy, “anyone here that can beat him?” The answer was no. So Chan told him basicly “stuff it” (actually, he said something about crabs that don’t smell too good and something about seeds withering for those of you who speak Cantonese).

One time, I showed up at the school of a famous Chinatown Sifu. My sifu was teaching this Chinese guy. I assumed he must be a senior student who the famous teacher wanted to get some extra stuff for. I can’t tell you how many big name teachers in the US paid my sifu to come and give them some extra stuff. The list is LONG and is BIG NAMES. Well, Sifu Chan hands him off to me like always. Like always, I proceed, in Cantonese. Prior to this, every time I taught, I was teaching guys who only spoke Cantonese. I went on for about an hour….

At the end of this hour, I heard the guy, in English ask me, “uh, do you speak English?” Poor guy, never had the courage to speak up before this. Apparently, he was ABC and didn’t speak Chinese. His sifu had set up the appointment, he’d shown up, been first confronted with Sifu Chan, then me! I’d rambled on for an hour in Cantonese, not one word of English…

My late teacher, Chan Tai-San

1 Sep

Learn more; Chan Tai San book at

The first time I saw Chan Tai San, I didn’t even know who he was, much less that I’d spend a good part of my life with him. I had heard some rumblings about him around Chinatown, particularly during the brief period I was lion dancing with the Dragon style people since Chan Tai San was teaching some Bak Mei and some of the Lung Ying people had sought him out to learn it. The rumblings were mixed, and at the time I wasn’t really that interested in finding a teacher. I was pretty much teaching my mixture of Hung Ga and Shuai Jiao, with some boxing and assorted other stuff I had picked up. I never really imagined how meeting him would shape my life so much.


I was sitting in a restaurant that no longer exists (and sadly so, it was a real landmark, at the turn of the century Sun Yat Sen had tea there while collecting money for his cause in NY). It was a little place, and mostly Chinese. But I managed to order my shrimp in rice noodle and my coffee and it was the sort of place that if you sat and BS’ed they didn’t care.


Old Chinese men arguing was nothing strange here, but one old guy was louder than the rest. He then suddenly stood up and proceeded to run through a line of movement. Now, I know it was bak Mei, at the time I just knew it was some sort of Kung Fu. Sifu Chan was already in his 60’s by the time this happened, yet he moved as if he was an active student in his 20’s!

After demonstrating the movement, he apparently must have felt he proved his point. The guy he was arguing with sort of put his head down, and Sifu Chan actually slapped his forehead. As I would later learn, Sifu Chan when it came to martial arts was ALWAYS right, and he wasn’t shy about telling you, showing you and pointing it out afterwards.

fei hok teui live

At this point, Steve Vventura, who was eating with me, had pulled our friend the waiter over. He was a man I’d get to know over the years and call “uncle”. I didn’t know either at the time, but he was a relative of Sifu Chan’s. He did Taiji and Tan Teui (spring legs) in the part every morning. His Taiji was his own synthetic form, he’d studied with like 20 different guys including version of yang, chen, wu, hao and li…

Anyway, my “uncle” as I would learn to call him, told us he was a famous teacher who had just arrived from China recently. He told us the name, which only sort of stuck, we were dumb lo faan who didn’t speak Chinese at the time. But he also told us he spoke no English and wasn’t exactly interviewing for students. A little crest fallen, I figured it wasn’t mean to be…. of course, I was wrong.

front cover art small

The same month I saw Chan Tai San in Tin Yik, Stephen Laurette came to me and Steve Ventura and asked us if we wanted to meet this old teacher he had studied with the year before. Laurette said that he’d lost track of the guy, but he had bumped into him the other day on the street and gotten his new address.

I met Stephen Laurette when I was doing Shuai Jiao with Jeng Hsin Ping. Laurette was an extremely skilled 7 Star Praying Mantis person, and also quite a scholar. He had studied with Sifu Chiu Leun in Chinatown for many years. Laurette had picked up quite a lot of Cantonese, and also could read and write pretty well. Like a lot of guys in TCMA, he wanted to learn more of the applications. For that reason, he decided to study Shuai Jiao to compliment his Mantis.

I had read the Shuai Jiao articles over the years and liked the idea of wrestling the “kung fu way”. I had done western wrestling and Hapkido, in addition to the Hung ga Kahm Na (Qin Na or Chin-Na). When I saw a flyer for Shuai Jiao lessons in NYC, I jumped at the opportunity and also found my way to the lower eastside, where I met Laurette.

Honestly, I grabbed Laurette the first day because he was the biggest guy there. I figured if I could learn to throw him, I could learn to throw anyone! But we ended up getting along for more than that. Laurette was always up to learn something new, and we ended up exchainging Mantis and Hung Ga over the years as well as doing Shuai Jiao together…

Laurette had met Chan tai San because Sifu Chan’s wife was Chiu Leun’s cousin. That’s just the way stuff worked in Chinatown those days. Laurette found Sifu Chan strange, to say the least, but could appreciate that he had stuff that apparently NO ONE else had… Sifu Chiu had told Laurette that Sifu Chan was a unique guy… that was true on many levels.

Laurette had studied Lama with Sifu Chan for about 8 months and then Sifu Chan left NY. He had gone back to Toronto, Canada for a while. I won’t tell you why now, some other time maybe…

When I met Laurette, he’d mentioned Sifu Chan to me, but since he wasn’t in NYC, it never was much of an issue. Then he came up to Steve Ventura and I and said that he’d just bumbed into Sifu Chan on the street and that if we wanted to meet him, he’d set up a meeting…

Here is the real kicker to this. At the time, I was teaching Hung Ga and Shuai Jiao. I’d done some Mantis, some dragon, a bunch of stuff, but I was pretty happy with what I was doing. I had no real desire to learn a new method. But I had one problem, the version of Hung Ga we did only had the 4 core forms. There were all long, and none were really fancy or pretty….

When I first asked to meet Sifu Chan, my initial desire was just to learn some pretty forms! That’s pretty f-in ironic in the long term…

We arranged to bring Sifu Chan to the space I was using for my own classes. Laurette translated. Sfu Chan asked if we would pay him $80 per month for lessons. He’d come a few times a week and teach us what we wanted. I forget the hows and whys, but Steve Ventura originally asked to learn Choy Lay Fut. Laurette and I decided to do Lama. Actually, I think Laurette had asked for a particular set already, Siu Lo Han.

Self defense is bull—t…….

26 Aug

The idea goes like this; people who aren’t interested in studying martial arts still need self defense, everyone needs to be able to defend themselves. So for years, people have offered self defense seminars and short term self defense programs. But the sad reality is, most of it is total bull—t. In fact, the entire idea is mostly bull—t.


Consider this, for centuries men who spent their entire lives training to be warriors, who trained with weapons, who went into battle with those weapons, with armor, fought and DIED. It is simple and it is straightforward, no amount of training can totally prepare you nor guarantee your success in a real fight. What is a “real fight”? Assaulted by surprise, by multiple attackers, conditioned criminals, larger, stronger, with weapons? How many people have fallen victim to the new “knockout” trend, where dumb (I mean really stupid) kids just walk up and punch someone?


Harsh reality, the best defense is to not be there. It’s awareness of the reality. It’s situational awareness. It’s not being a deluded dimwit like the 100 lbs woman who was a Taekwondo black belt and “sparring champion” (in POINT FIGHTING) who thought she was such a badass she’d hang out in bars and talk crap to men twice her size. She was found dead in a ditch along the road one day.


Of course, if you are in a profession where your life is regularly threatened; a police officer, a correction officer, etc…. you need specialized training. But without the awareness, it’s fantasy role playing. Note one of the best programs for this sort of thing, called “DIE LESS OFTEN“. I love the name, and the strange look on people’s faces when they first hear the name. DIE LESS OFTEN. It’s fu–ing brilliant. And we don’t have much brilliance in the martial arts community…..

Martial arts is NOT a game of tag!

25 Aug

In retrospect, I was sort of lucky. My first martial arts experiences were boxing (PAL program as a little kid) and Taekwondo (Moo Duk Kwan under the late Pong Ki Kim). There is no such thing as “point sparring” or light contact in boxing. The Taekwondo I learned was full contact, the old school style with out pads and full contact kicks to the head and body. So I suppose I never associated martial arts with anything other than full contact.


In Chinese martial arts, I came to learn that when most Chinese refer to sparring, they are NOT talking about full contact. I can’t say why, but among most Chinese sparring is a game of tag. It is some sort of cultural bias. Even my own teacher was guilty. He told me a guy was going to visit from Canada. He told me the guy was really good at sparring/fighting. When the Canadian arrived, we invited him to spar, and frankly he was terrible. We embarrassed him in front of Chan Tai San. Then we asked Chan Tai San why he had said the guy was good? Chan Tai San ignored us.


After Chan Tai San had passed away, the hing-dai met a teacher who has also been a coach in Guangdong. He had just arrived and was looking for students, he tried very hard to convert us. Over tea, he told us that among all the coaches he was the best at sparring. He said he had beaten all the other coaches. Stephen Innocenzi, a training brother of mine, asked if that meant that he had beaten Chan Tai San. The teacher shook his hand violently and was very clear, NO! For him sparring was like a game of tag. He said no one wanted to spar Chan Tai San, because for Chan Tai San sparring always meant full contact. Despite the one Canadian debacle, that had been my experience with Chan Tai San.


However, I had consistently and continuously seen people called “good fighters” who could never demonstrate more than light contact games of tag. It annoyed me, it still annoys me, that this was the standard in Chinese martial arts. But it sure does explain a lot!

The Chan Tai San Lama Pai book is still available at

The lost concept of commitment

1 Aug

I was obviously a child, but I dragged my parents into the late Pong Ki-Kim’s Taekwondo/Hapkido Dojang and begged them to sign me up. My father was afraid I wouldn’t actually go, so he signed me up for the “yellow belt program” which was just three months. Of course, he had to renew my membership and the rest is history. That’s because I knew what I wanted and I was committed to it; I wanted to be a black belt. I didn’t know how long it would take, but I was going to do it.


Not long after I met Chan Tai-San, he wanted me to make a commitment to him. He was worried that I didn’t understand him enough, so he got someone to translate. They asked me if I was willing to commit to Sifu Chan and follow the path. It wasn’t a hard question, YES. I knew Chan Tai-San had real knowledge and I wanted that knowledge. And I was willing to do what had to be done to be his student.


Among the many changes I am seeing in today’s population, without a doubt a major change is a total lack of commitment. I can’t begin to tell you how many people tell me they want to “fight” but can’t commit to the necessary time to train. Fighting isn’t easy, and training is a MUST. But the reality is, I see more people who want to talk about fighting, act like they fight, but not actually train.


I no longer teach kung fu in the traditional format, but I still get flooded with requests for me to accept a few students and teach them the “traditional way.” Recently, I did just that; offered to open up a traditional kung fu class. My in box was SWAMPED with email. I told people they would have to commit to three days a week and commit to train at least six months; half the people couldn’t do that they said. I dedicated 16 years of my life, six days a week, to Chan Tai-San. They wouldn’t dedicate 72 hours…


The smallest membership I have at my school equates to about a 3 month commitment. If you want to learn martial arts, you need three months to learn the basics. Even if you are just into it for fitness, it takes three months to learn the workout and see results; determine if it is really going to work for you. Still, about 30% of the people who come in can’t make that commitment (or so they say?). If you are doing another activity, another form of exercise, ok MAYBE I can get that, but most frequently, when I ask them if they are doing any other exercise, they say NO. They aren’t even willing to commit to their own health and wellness. I have an option as cheap as $75 per month, that’s $2.70 a day. You aren’t willing to spend $2.70 a day to be healthier and live longer? Dear lord!


If we are looking for reasons why Chinese martial arts are in crisis; this is part of the story for sure. Even in the past, Chinese martial arts was a unique commitment. How can we expect it to continue to function in that format in a culture where people aren’t willing to spend $2.70?

The worst lie……

30 Jul

Today, I am going to take the dark comedy debacle of Gus Kaparos and draw from it an important lesson for all martial artists. No, I am being perfectly serious. The title of today’s blog might give you a hint. Yesterday, I friend of mine sent me a screen capture of Gus Kaparos, owner of Green Cloud Kung Fu in Patchogue, proclaiming that upon reflection, he had actually won his fight with Novell Bell.


We probably need to back up a bit; Gus Kaparos apparently is a habitual liar. In a Sinovision USA interview he did recently, he not only lied about the year he met Chan Tai-San. Gus Kaparos told tales about studying Muay Thai since the age of 10, about beating multiple opponents at once in street fights and about beating up an instructor and taking the keys to his school. The stories were so improbable they inspired a parody video by a former, disgruntled student of his.

Tall tales are not the only thing Gus Kaparos specializes in. He has challenged a number of people to fights, only to find ways to avoid actually fighting. He did it so frequently, it became a joke on Gene Ching’s Kung Fu forum.


Gus Kaparos is clearly a pathological liar, but former students have also suggested he has a drinking problem. So perhaps that explains why he doesn’t even keep track of the lies he tells and apparently talked himself into a fight with Novell Bell. Video of the fight should have told the whole story. Gus Kaparos clearly has very little sparring experience, questionable skills and clearly LOST….


I should mention that this was almost two months ago. It was being quickly forgotten. Yet yesterday, Gus Kaparos of Green Cloud Kung Fu in Patchogue Long Island New York took to facebook to revise history and claim he really won his fight with Novell “Black Taoist” Bell. On facebook, Gus Kaparos said
“I walked in the ring injured recovering from back surgery that almost left me in a wheel chair”. However, there are SCREEN CAPTURES from before the fight where Gus claimed he was in perfect health and said he would make “no excuses” for any injuries!


Gus Kaparos then said “Novel chose to try to blind me with an open finger thrust.” Watch the video at the end of this blog, THIS NEVER HAPPENED.

Gus Kaparos then says “Saying that it was a TKO was a lie! There was no standing eight count and I immediately got back on my feet”. Novell has now released the UNEDITED TAPE. It shows Gus Kaparos’ friends and students giving him extended rests, trying desperately to save Gus from himself.

Gus Kaparos said “In the second round I could have finished him off with a guillotine choke.” Watch this video, and try not to laugh so hard that you hurt yourself. Gus Kaparos has no idea what a Guillotine Choke is!

Gus Kaparos said “The rest of the time I was using my Kung Fu to control his little tantrum”. If by “control” he means getting punched in the face, kicked around the ring and not being able to block a single knee strike?

Gus Kapros then says “The real Sifus that know their stuff could very easily see that I was was calmly controlling a much larger healthier adversary”.

Gus Kaparos said ” I Spoke to other Sifus and they felt the only Technical loss was on Novell’s part”

Watch the video, the man is living in a fantasy land of his own construction. Unable to accept reality.

I have to seriously question how anyone in the martial arts community can still stand behind a man who has been proven a liar of this magnitude. Gus Kaparos wants to talk about “honor” but clearly he has none. Do people not have any self respect anymore?

BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY, even if this story initially appears to you to have no relationship to you in any way, IT DOES….

It is unethical and dishonorable to lie about your training, your qualifications and what you teach. it is inexcusable to lie to your students. But the worst lie?


You might have found this by searching:

Green Cloud Martial Arts | Gus Kaparos | green cloud kung fu | greencloud kung fu | green cloud gus kaparos | green cloud kung fu martial arts | green cloud kung fu academy | green cloud kung fu reviews | gus kaparos kung | green cloud kung fu merrick | sifu gus kaparos | gus kaparos facebook | green cloud gus kaparos | gus kaparos kung fu | kung fu sifu gus kaparos | gus kaparos | sifu gus kaparos | green cloud gus kaparos

Traditional Kung Fu tactics that WORK….

29 Jul

Traditional Chinese martial arts, AKA “Kung Fu,” has a pretty horrible reputation in today’s martial arts world. As I have previously posted in regards to this, much of it has to do with the culture that has developed; the wrong people in charge, the wrong attitudes, “posers”, “wannabes”, talking about fighting but not fighting, not understanding fighting, etc. Regardless, that does NOT mean that there are not applicable skills in traditional Chinese martial arts.

jaat tactic one

This first picture I post shows a combination of two tactics I am very fond of. The first is the “cross kick” to the shin. Hard to see, effective in not only creating opportunities but also very damaging. There is a similar kick in French Savate, and we combine methods a lot in my school. Here it is combined with using the hand as a distraction, a proven method in real fights.

pek to inside vs jab

Using “pek teui” / “bahk hok tam soi” against the inside of the rear leg. I recommend you wait until they jab, putting their weight forward and turning out their lead leg.

spin hook kick

Again, use the hands to distract. Throw a jab, set up a spin kick….

pek into chaai

When they lift their leg to avoid the Pek Teui, use the same leg to launch a Chaai Teui!

Remember, the Chan Tai San book is still available at

“A Killing Art,” Taekwondo history you probably never heard…

28 Jul


Today’s blog is actually a book review. As many know, I am a trained historian and former history teacher. Thus, I have greeted a new wave of more academically rigorous, neutral perspective martial arts books with great enthusiasm. I am also a major book addict, I read non-stop. Finally, with a 2nd degree black belt in WTF Taekwondo (but from a school where the Moo Duk Kwan banner still hung and the curriculum was so different that my instructor was frequently sanctioned by the WIF) and a Korean wife and father-in-law who also trained in Moo Duk Kwan, I was attracted to “A Killing Art: The Untold History of Taekwondo” by Alex Gillis.

The idea that the standard Taekwondo history presented by so many of its Korean teachers is not quite right is hardly a new idea. I trained in the 1980’s and watched them drop the Palgwe forms for the Taegeuk forms. So much for reverence for forms that were supposed to be “thousands of years old.” It also didn’t take a genius to notice that the Palgwe forms resembled karate forms. Of course, then there is the nasty little fact that you can find old “Tang Soo Do” books where you notice that “Tang Soo Do” in Japanese reads “Karate Do” and the forms are in fact SHOTOKAN FORMS.

Alex Gillis is not Korean. He is a long time student of Taekwondo, and at times you still see hints of both naivete and hero worship, but at least he is willing to acknowledge the thousand pound gorilla in the room. The founding fathers of “Tae Kwon Do” were all men who studied Shotokan, but in the post war period were loath to remain affiliated with Japan, a country which had occupied, tortured and humiliated Korea.

The Chung Do Kwan was in the Japanese occupation period a Shotokan school, not much more to it than that. The infamous General Choi Hong-Hi and Nam Tae Hi were also shotokan students…. MAJOR CON: The book remains almost exclusively focused on General Choi and his rivalry with the World Taekwondo Federation (WTF). While there are several pictures of Hwang Kee, founder of the Moo Duk Kwan, he is in fact NOT MENTIONED ONCE that I remember. For a history of Taekwondo, to not even mention Hwang Kee, especially when discussing obscuring Japanese origins and the politics of unifying all the Kwan, is regretful.

As I mentioned, the obscuring of the Japanese origins, the creation of a new name and the creation of the “Korean martial art” myth, the false linking of Korean traditional Taekkyeon to modern Taekwondo, etc., is no longer all that controversial and surprising. The political corruption, the unbridled use of violence and questionable morals of the major players will be the real surprise here.


I had long heard that General Choi was a “traitor” who had gone to North Korea. But the extent to which he compromised his morals and coddled a brutal totalitarian regime in the quest to satisfy his own ego will probably still shock you. Un Young Kim, whose signature appears on my black belt certificates, actually ended up in prison because of his corruption, yet you’ll still be shocked to see how far it went, and how unprincipled the men who used to lecture us on morality really were. This book documents how the two “international” federations existed to line the pockets of their leadership, were unquestionably corrupt and in many ways just down right racist.

For those of us in the martial arts industry, you’ll also be shocked to learn that in return for using their Taekwondo muscle to suppress (read as “beat into submission and frequently kidnap”) democratic forces protesting Korea’s military dictatorship, the Korean CIA (KCIA) gave hundreds of thousands to dollars to instructors and helped them set up their Dojang. Korean Taekwondo did not just have “good business sense”, they were being secretly funded by both the KCIA, and even more amusingly, but Reverend Moon’s cult!

Of course, the instructors interviewed all deny that they PERSONALLY benefited, it was always some other instructor…

While I really wish the book had addressed Hwang Kee and the Moo Duk Kwan, and discuss the process by which the Kwan were FORCED to unify, the book still provides tons of sometimes whispered by never openly discussed topics. It is well worth the read. You can find it at


Kung Fu: land of bulls–t……

25 Jul


Today’s blog, a bit of a rant, but also a real look at how a pervasive culture does have consequences. I can’t say I have a definitive answer as to why, though I can suggest a few reasons, but if you’ve spent any time at all in the Wu Lin / Mo Lam (Chinese martial arts community) you can’t help but notice that it resembles far too much a bunch of old women sitting around gossiping and talking smack.


I have told this story before. A classmate of mine was in China and ended up having lunch with a fairly well known teacher. Chinese societal convention dictated that my classmate pay for that lunch, as the junior. According to my classmate, he DID pay for lunch. But according to the teacher, my classmate did not….



Let’s all stop and remind ourselves that all of this has to do with who paid for LUNCH.

The teacher in China has a student in the United States. I’ve never met the guy. He’s never met me, never been inside my school, etc. I should also note that when I met Chan Tai-San, the guy was three years old. So, by the time this guy started practicing, I wasn’t even spending time in the community. We’ll call the guy “Dexter” (not his real name)…

I found out Dexter took it upon himself to talk badly about me because, get this, he heard my classmate didn’t pay for lunch with his teacher…. It is what I call “kung fu stupid.”

And “kung fu stupid” is pervasive. It even exists among those who studied under Chan Tai-San. I’ve told a story about a guy coming into the Duk Chan in NYC’s Chinatown one night and challenging Chan Tai-San. Chan Tai-San punched the guy in the solar plexus and that was it. The only people present were Stephen Laurette and myself. Yet I’ve heard a bunch of my classmates tell the story, get the details completely wrong, and insert themselves into the story. Apparently, lies aren’t just OK in the kung-fu world, they are the currency.


Actually, it gets worse. On Gene Ching’s kung-fu forum, a classmate (I loath to admit he is a classmate but he was) told an ABSURD story about Chan Tai-San. It was right up there with “he ripped his heart out and showed it to him while the heart was still beating.” This wasn’t just the case of someone remembering the details of the story differently, it was just an outright LIE.. NOT ONE OF CHAN TAI-SAN’s STUDENTS REMEMBERS ANYTHING REMOTELY LIKE THIS STORY.. just that guy. And frankly, it was embarrassing to be associated with such bullsh-t.


Many know that a number of years ago, I had a bare knuckle fight, locked door, under “old rules.” It was the result of a rather heated argument on a public form (and after the fact, a huge misunderstanding). However, the fact remains, There were only six people in that room; the person I fought, me, that person’s friend, two of my students and a “referee.” For a number of reasons; tradition, that it was a misunderstanding that started it, that it was no one else’s business, etc; the people who were in that room have not talked about the fight much/at all. Yet, of course, I’ve seen people who weren’t even in the room, who weren’t even in THE STATE, describe it… “well I heard it form a guy“… yeah, another guy who WAS NOT THERE… laundry women, old wives tales… aren’t you supposed to be an ADULT?

My personal opinion, the Chinese martial arts community now TALKS ABOUT FIGHTING; because they no longer actually fight! It’s all talk, actually it’s all gossip and bullsh-t.

And when I listen to them talk, I realize they don’t understand fighting at all. I have heard a few “kung fu people” discuss a fight I was present for. We’ll say between “X” and “Y”… It is pretty remarkable how many people in the kung fu world think “Y” actually “won” that fight….. Because “X stalled” I often heard.

When someone keeps their distance, waits for you to attack, isn’t hit by your attack, and kicks you in the legs until you give up, they did not “stall”… they did not “lose”….. they won

“Y” is of course a kung fu person and “X” is a despised Jeet Kung Do guy….

F–k! I listen to kung-fu people talk about fighting and realize they do not understand fighting at all…..

Headlocks aren’t “chokes”. Kung-fu has kicks and punches; if you kick and punch it doesn’t make it “just kickboxing.” Chinese martial arts has wrestling!

Kung-fu people just HATE Mixed Martial Arts, but their student base is no different than the “MMA fan boys” they hate so much… that’s the honest truth…


Kung Fu books….

24 Jul

Almost as soon as I started training in New York’s Chinatown, I discovered Chinese book stores and kung fu books. Now, mind you, this was years before I met Chan Tai-San and long before I could speak or write Chinese. I’d just look at the pictures and try to figure out what the book was about.


It was kind of fun to go back years later and find out what I had bought, not knowing what they really were. I had both the Hap Ga “Siu Lo Han” book and Chan Daau’s “Do Pai” books.

south fist one

The first Chinese martial arts system I learned was Hung Ga, so I of course acquired the three famous Hung Ga books. I also managed to collect a few other Hng Ga and other “Nam Kyuhn” books. I was young, I had just started Chinese martial arts, and I couldn’t even read the books I was buying. At first, I was looking for books to learn styles, or at least forms from those styles. I remember I did learn a Choy Lay Fut crane set, a tiger set that was just labeled “Shaolin” and a tiger fork set from these books.

kahm na 3

People who collected these books probably remember how little application was addressed. Initially, I’d say almost all the books I bought showed the sets but almost none of the applications. Were they “keeping their secrets”? Or just didn’t have any applications to show? It seemed like the only application books were Chin Na/Kahm Na (grappling) books.

kahm na 6a

Why was Chin Na/Kahm Na the only application skill you could find in book form? I can’t tell you. I can tell you much of the technique in these books were silly wrist locks that would never work in real life. They were also, characteristic of much Chinese martial arts, pretty horribly organized and presented. Only one was rather brilliant, showing the attack, the Chin Na response and then the counter to the Chin Na. I may translate that one for you all one day.

quan fa

In the 1990’s, after I had met Chan Tai-San, and as I learned some Chinese, a new sort of book started to appear in these book stores. Suddenly, there were books with nothing but applications? I have been told that “sanshou” manuals were initialy considered only for the military and police and that you could get into significant trouble for having them in the 1970’s and early 1980’s. Then, suddenly, things changed.


At some point, the Chinese Wushu Association decided that sanshou, which had been military and police training, was going to become an international sport. The first world championship was held in Beijing in 1991 and suddenly not only was it no longer illegal to have sanshou manuals, they started publishing them!

throwing pages

I have a rather extensive collection of these books, including reprints of the original 1956 military manual called just “sanshou.” They are a strange collection of trends. Many are filled with illustrations of people in traditional kung fu uniforms. Others show western “track suits” to indicate how modern the methods are. Most are bare knuckle, a few show boxing gloves. Some are almost desperate to show the applications of traditional Chinese martial art. Others are clearly mis-moshes including clearly non Chinese martial arts. A few seem to have lifted their illustrations from Japanese Judo and Russian Sambo manuals. Addresses all this will have to be another project.

In the meantime, my Chan Tai-San Lama Pai book is still available at


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 306 other followers

%d bloggers like this: